what is

Non-qualifying withdrawal: what cancelling really costs

July 31, 2026 Comments Off on Non-qualifying withdrawal: what cancelling really costs

A non-qualifying withdrawal is when you take money out of the Altersvorsorgedepotbefore the decumulation phase begins. The state then reclaims all allowances and tax advantages. You will still be paid something, just considerably less than the account balance suggests.

Table of contents

  1. What counts as non-qualifying?
  2. What exactly is reclaimed
  3. What is expressly allowed
  4. The better solution when money is tight
  5. Two examples
  6. Frequently asked questions

What counts as non-qualifying?

The Altersvorsorgedepot (Germany’s state-subsidized retirement investment account) is subsidized capital with a clear purpose. The state adds money so that you have more in old age, and because the subsidy comes from tax revenue it is tied to this one use and no other. If you withdraw earlier, you are using it for a purpose it was not intended for. The logic is that simple.

In concrete terms this covers cancelling the contract with payout of the balance and any withdrawal before the agreed start of retirement. What you need the money for makes no difference. Renovation, a trip around the world, an emergency: the reclaim is always the same.

Is this a penalty?
No. In legal terms, a subsidy whose precondition no longer applies is simply reversed. In financial terms it still feels like one.

What exactly is reclaimed

Three things happen at once. That is what makes it expensive.

Item What happens to it
Basic allowance and child allowance are reclaimed in full, for all years
Tax advantage from the special expenses deduction is reversed
Price gains in the securities account stay with you, but are taxable
Your own contributions stay with you

The longer the contract runs, the larger the subsidized share becomes, and with it the sum that has to flow back if you cancel. Cancelling after twenty years therefore costs considerably more than cancelling after two, even though the percentage rule is the same.

For a sense of scale: If you have received the full basic allowance for twenty years, that alone comes to €10,800 to be paid back. With two children over eighteen years, a further €10,800 is added.

What is expressly allowed

Not every movement in the securities account triggers the reclaim. The following actions, among others, remain harmless.

  • Switching to another provider, as long as the balance is transferred and not paid out.
  • Shifting between funds inside the securities account.
  • Suspending contributions, that is, pausing your payments.
  • The one-off partial lump-sum withdrawal of up to 30 percent at the start of retirement.
  • The move into a life annuity or drawdown plan from the agreed age.

The difference between transfer and payout is the most important one of all. If, when switching, you accidentally have the balance transferred to your current account, you have cancelled. Even if you meant something quite different, and even if the money goes straight into a new contract of the same type afterwards.

The better solution when money is tight

When money is short, cancelling is almost never the right answer. Suspending contributions costs nothing. Nothing at all. The contract lies dormant. The balance stays invested, the subsidy received so far is secure, and you can start paying in again at any time.

You only lose the subsidy for the years in which you pay nothing in, and that does not come back. Measured against a reclaim covering two decades, that is a small price. If you can manage at least the minimum own contribution of €120 a year, you even stay fully within the subsidy.

Two examples

Bianca, 44, needs €8,000 at short notice for a car repair and the deposit on a new apartment. Her securities account stands at €31,000. Cancelling would claw back allowances from fourteen years and make the price gains taxable. Instead she suspends contributions for two years and takes out a small installment loan. On balance that is the cheaper option.

Kai, 39, is switching provider because he finds the reduction in yield (RIY) too high. He instructs a transfer of the balance, not a payout. The subsidy is retained in full; only the old provider’s switching costs arise.

Frequently asked questions about non-qualifying withdrawals

Do I get nothing at all if I cancel?

You do. Your own contributions and the price gains stay with you. The allowances and the tax advantage are deducted, and the gains are taxed.

Does an emergency count as an exception?

Under the procedure so far, no. Unemployment, illness or divorce make no difference to the reclaim.

What happens in the event of death?

Inheritance is a separate matter. How the subsidy is treated depends on who inherits. This question has not yet been finally clarified for the Altersvorsorgedepot.

Can I borrow against the securities account?

Borrowing against it is not provided for. The capital is not available as collateral.

Is a withdrawal for a property possible?

Whether there is a qualifying use for owner-occupied residential property is open. We will add it as soon as it can be documented.

How do I find out how large the reclaim would be?

Your provider can quantify the amount. Ask for it before you cancel, not afterwards.

What should you take away?
Cancelling is expensive, pausing is free. If you temporarily cannot manage the money, suspend contributions and let the contract lie dormant.

Last updated: July 2026. Sources: BMF, German federal government, Bundestag printed paper 21/4088, Deutsche Rentenversicherung.

Keep calculating and reading

Altersvorsorgedepot calculator Plus — calculate the subsidy, tax advantage and final balance for your own situation.

All terms at a glance: Glossary from A to Z.

Official sources and further information

Verwandte Artikel